Monday, 16 December 2019

Watchmen: The Ultimate Cut

Cast: Jackie Earle Haley, Patrick Wilson, and Carla Gugino

Director: Zack Snyder

215 minutes (18) 2009
Paramount 4K Ultra HD

Rating: 9/10
Review by Christopher Geary 

Zack Snyder’s three and a half-hour SF-horror magnum opus adds Tales Of The Black Freighter to extra footage of Watchmen: The Director’s Cut, which extended the 162-minute theatrical edition of Watchmen to 186 minutes. The animated sequences of Black Freighter are woven into its live-action with comic-book framing shots for a pirate-ship adventure (voice-over by Gerard Butler) bringing meta-textural qualities to this epic movie. In essence, the inclusion of this story-within-a-story delivers welcome breaks in the main narrative but never detracts from the feature’s scattered oddments of character shading in the longer version. This notable inclusion of traditional animation actually enhances by association the flickering montages of the main-title scenes, accompanied by Bob Dylan’s anthemic song, in already one of the most impressive such slow-motion sequences in today’s cinema, now recognised as a creative highlight of the whole picture.


“Why does death pass me by?”


What makes Watchmen such a classic of superhero movies - after Ang Lee’s Hulk (2003), and Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight (2008) - and in retrospect a landmark of 21st century cinema in general, is director Snyder’s astute blending of radically varied, yet exquisitely balanced, satirical tropes and sub-genres still typically avoided by nearly all of its screen competitors, like the Avengers and X-Men franchises. Watchmen embraces modern film noir and gumshoe movie style within its urban vigilante motifs for the morally bleak and uncompromising Rorschach character. Setting this alongside the exotic physics of weird SF in a backdrop to Dr Manhattan’s origin, itself twinned with the innate complexity of stunning alternative history that spans generations, from post-war Minutemen to their successor team, the Watchmen, while also offering a sinister political conspiracy for widescreen war-movie dramatics in Vietnam scenes, that builds up to apocalyptic imagery of WW3 via SQUID-tech events.


Costumed heroics of characters with secret identities like Nite Owl, particularly effective in a night-blaze rescue mission and jail-break sequence, contrasts magnificently with all the horror show elements of serial-killer violence and grisly animation of Black Freighter’s supernatural events. Although twin enigmas Rorschach and Dr Manhattan might seem to be figures of primary interest here, it is anti-hero the Comedian (killer of presidents and pregnant victims) who is the pivotal character. Portrayed in this scratch-built universe as an alternative history’s deeply twisted flip-side answer to Marvel’s patriotic super–soldier Captain America, homicidal brute the Comedian makes crazy depressives like Rorschach seem tame, as far as ‘inspirational’ champions go. His role in events certainly makes the movie a great screen version of writer Alan Moore’s seminal and tremendously influential ‘satirical deconstruction’ of superheroes.


“Who wants a cowboy in the White House?”


Daring asides into sexual violence against original Silk Spectre (Carla Gugino) is offset by romantic comedy (mostly involving Malin Ackerman, whose Laurie also becomes the first woman on Mars) explores territory for two glamorous action heroines that is rarely charted in more main-stream superhero movies. Finally, Watchmen asks is any utopia that’s based upon a lie... worth accepting or not? What if a wholly united world remains a strictly unhappy ending?


A comicbook adaptation that, perhaps, is simply too faithful to its graphic-novel source, locked into a narrative and its darkly witty sub-texts, which might have benefited from updating beyond the contexts of its mid-1980s’ geopolitics, and that alternative-world’s cultural zeitgeist, to 21st century concerns, this ultimate Watchmen arrives just in time to be viewed as an important work in the last 20 years of superhero cinema to rival standalone masterpiece Hulk.


Re-mastered version of Watchmen: The Ultimate Cut looks absolutely extraordinary in 4K UHD with stunning use of colour and sound.  
Bonus material on a Blu-ray disc includes featurettes:
  • The Phenomenon: The Comic That Changed Comics
  • Real Super Heroes, Real Vigilantes
  • Mechanics: Technologies Of A Fantastic World
  • 11 Watchmen ‘making of’ webisodes
  • My Chemical Romance ‘Desolation Row’ music video


No comments:

Post a Comment